Hikers and Developer Clash in Franklin Canyon
Ritz-Carlton developer plans to bulldoze Mayberry.
Nestled between Studio City and Beverly Hills, a pristine nature haven known as Franklin Canyon is about to be desecrated. The controversy is pitting a popular hiking trail against building development by Mohamed Hadid, who says he has his right to build luxury homes there.
Franklin Canyon is a big part of Los Angeles history, from TV shows like Mayberry RFD, Fantasy Island and Batman to oil and water. This unspoiled wilderness is slated to be developed for large homes along the ridgeline.
Locals said they felt that when the last house had been built they thought they could live with that because the trails were still intact. Then, a bulldozer came along and then fences were erected across the popular Hastain trail, bisecting some 45 acres of his property. In effect, he ruined a hike, a view and the land.
Hadid told the Los Angeles Daily News that his permits were not expired. He did, in fact, begin grading with a long-expired permit, according to local resident Rob Warner.
I joined hikers, calling themselves a grass-roots group, Save Franklin Canyon, lead up by Ellen Scott this past weekend to see what she and the other protesters hoped to achieve in salvaging Hastain Trail. It has been there since 1967. Some of the elderly stayed below, a couple with twins came up and soon a group of about 60 had crossed paths going up or down the hillside.
Conversation was met with hope and handheld signs, in all colors and shapes. From Sunland, North Hollywood, Valley Village, Studio City, Toluca Lake, Hollywood, West Hollywood, Beverly Hills, and more, communities from all around were represented.
| 9650 N ROYALTON DR 90210 |
| APPLICATION/ PERMIT NUMBER | PC / JOB NUMBER | TYPE | STATUS | STATUS DATE | EXCERPT OF WORK DESCRIPTION |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 04010 30000 00643 | B04WL00140 | Bldg-New | Permit Expired | 05/12/2008 | new carport |
| 04010 30000 00523 | B04WL00140 | Bldg-New | Permit Expired | 03/07/2011 | NEW SFD 1208SF |
| 01030 10000 02968 | G01LA00202 | Grading | Corrections Issued | 01/25/2002 | SITE PREP FOR DWG ( cut 239,461 CY, fill cy, import cy , |
| 04030 30000 00317 | B04WL00140 | Grading | Permit Expired | 02/24/2011 | GRADING FOR THE SITE PREPARATION. CUT 11980 CY, FILL 11040 CY AND EXPORT 940 CY |
| 01020 10000 03698 | G01LA00202 | Nonbldg-New | PC Unassigned | 12/28/2001 | RET WALLS FOR ENTRY DRIVEWAY TO NEW DWG. |
| 04020 30000 00415 | B04WL00140 | Nonbldg-New | Permit Expired | 05/12/2008 | NEW RETAINING WALL MAX 23 FEET HIGH. TOTAL LENGTH = 4582 FT. |
There was a sense of frustration among the many hikers. All have hiked for more than a decade on these hills. They talked over how they had been lied to about the construction activity, the intent and an unforeseen future for this little-known pocket of hiking trail.
One man sighed and said, "If this was Runyon Canyon, we'd have thousands of hikers show up!"
Scott is a North Hollywood resident, has been hiking the trail for 25 years and has four grown children.
She recalled, “When we first saw a dirt road being bulldozed up close to the peak of the Hastain Trail in January and February of 2011, and asked why, we were told the same thing, that it was something to do with the Conservancy and creating drainage for water. I remember saying, 'Oh, so you're working for the Conservancy?' and the guys said, 'Yes.'"
Then, she said, "I hiked up on February 13th and saw bulldozers grading the land I knew they needed to be stopped but I didn't know how. It was late and I ran down the hill and went home. I painted the John Muir quote: 'Everybody needs beauty as well as bread, places to play in and pray in, where nature may heal and give strength to the body and soul,' on a white sheet."
Scott said she decided to take as stand, “On the morning of February 15th I observed much more activity near the peak. My daughter and close friend accompanied me to the top and took pictures. I put some flimsy stakes in the ground in front of the bulldozer to support my sign. The operator stopped the bulldozer when I walked up. He then contacted someone. Eventually numerous 'bosses' attempted to get me to leave."
Scott added, "Finally, Mohamed Hadid himself came roaring up in his SUV. I remember his shoes. He had some expensive leather loafer looking shoe that shouted out that he is one who 'drives' to get to where he is going. He is not about to hike. How could he possibly relate. Mohamed told me that I seemed like a nice lady so I should understand that and leave his property."
Finally Hadid and his foreman left.
Page Ostrow, of Los Angeles, has been hiking the trail since 1986.
“This trail, for us, is our home," Ostrow said. "We were shocked when suddenly he put a fence in the middle of, what felt like, our living room. We've had weddings, proposals, memorials in this canyon.”
A loud whirring of a chopper overhead came down near us and we pondered aloud if Hadid was in the bird as it hovered briefly and took off. Photos were taken and plans made. What had started as a few hikers talking to one another has slowly evolved into a village of people who love their canyon and are committed to keeping her as intact and preserved for future as possible.
Last month Hadid Development began grading private land and was halted by Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety. Mohamed Hadid was found to have commenced work without a permit. Hadid Development began grading again on March 14 but quickly was shut down by Building and Safety due to the vigilance of Save Franklin Canyon.
Warner said, “We inundated the city and building inspector with calls when we saw the bulldozers up there and another stop work order was issued, this time with the ‘citation warning’ that was supposed to be attached to the previous stop work order. It is unclear to me why no consequence is suffered when violation after violation is ignored.”
The Santa Monica Mountains Conservancy or Mountains Recreation and Conservation Authority (MRCA) was funded with monies to acquire the six subject properties located on the ridgeline dividing Coldwater and Franklin Canyons. At the time they were owned by five separate owners and by law, the MRCA cannot pay more than appraised value for the property.
In 2005, after an appraisal was done, although the MRCA had the money to acquire the properties, the individual owners declined to sell. Without MRCA’s knowledge, Hadid bought up all of the lots at a price over appraisal in 2005. A typical Hadid way of doing business, he has been quoted as saying, “Buy high, sell even higher.”
After several approaches and rebuffs, between 2005-2008, the MRCA had another appraisal done in 2008, the fair market valuation was still not high enough for Hadid.
Hadid, known for his many Ritz Carlton’s, started his business in Washington D.C. then branched out to Aspen – to Mexico – to huge mansions in Beverly Hills. Hadid states he gets death threats and hikers are damaging his equipment and fences. Calls to Hadid remain unanswered.
D.J. James, of Hollywood, said, “Just a month ago, there were beautiful trails up there and now it looks like a Wal-Mart parking lot. I’ve hiked this trail for over 20 years.”
James says about the man ruining the canyon, “As a developer Mr. Hadid has a responsibility to build with a conscience. . . . I have no respect for him and will approach him with caution in any dealings I may have with him.”
Since the trail fencing occurred, MRCA staff has approached Hadid about selling a trail easement. The hikers would love a meeting with Hadid, and he said he has agreed that common ground and civil discussions are a must” but as of this writing, he refused.
We came down off the hillside leaving our signs and mascot Conan with Colbert and Stewart in a homage to The Three Stooges. Rains were starting to drizzle but spirits were high.
Hadid initially said he planned to erect five or six homes on his land that is zoned for up to 11.
The two sides said they are still willing to have discussions about some sort of compromise.
For more information about the fight to keep the land from being devloped, contact www.savefranklincanyon.com.
For more information about Hadid, see his webside: www.mohamedhadid.com.
E.M. Fredric
9:36 pm on Sunday, March 27, 2011
Look for Conan and his Stooges in the canyons and on Mulholland as the next meeting to save Franklin Canyon (www.savefranklincanyon.com) convenes on Monday night in Franklin Canyon at 7pm. Our kids need our hills !
Nicole
5:49 pm on Wednesday, March 30, 2011
Thank you so much for raising awareness! It is such an incredible place. we must save it
E.M. Fredric
8:27 pm on Wednesday, March 30, 2011
Thank you, Nicole! The more awareness we raise, the more chance we have of saving our canyons. We have little land left in this town to walk, hike or bike let alone have a picnic. There are several articles out, one about property available and how those hikers are an issue and now send in your photos to show what's green? We need someone to find what land we have remaining before Hadid Development or another developer sneaks in and builds while we're sleeping. If you care about your Farmer's Market, please care about our land that's left.
steve
10:16 pm on Wednesday, March 30, 2011
Thank you for bringing awareness to the development going on at a beloved Los Angeles Canyon/nature trail. As a local valley resident and Angeleno of course, it is very important to raise the awareness of fellow Angelenos on the continued depletion of our few natural sanctuaries. Hopefully others will be introduced to Franklin Canyon and will understand the necessity to preserve it.
Ellen Scott
10:24 pm on Wednesday, March 30, 2011
It's great that you are covering this attempted devastation of the Hastain Trail in Franklin Canyon. Thank you! Folks should check out the site www.savefranklincanyon.com and check the 'New Events' tab for information on a fundraising picnic we are planning. This event is not posted yet but will be up soon.
anthony Santavenere
3:14 am on Thursday, March 31, 2011
Iv ben going to Franklin canyon fore Attleast 25 years I love the Duck's and I would hate to see anything happen to this woderfull place altho @ the stop sign @ the end of the one way streat or road there is a camera so please if you do go there make shure you STOP because if not you will get a nice letter in the mail with picture's of your car and A really nice TICKET FORE $175.00 but I still love the place and will continue to go there P/S ANTHONY SANTAVENERE .
Rob Warner
11:43 am on Thursday, March 31, 2011
I want to know where Tyler Perry stands. His home is nearing completion just beyond the peak of the Hastain Trail, which has been placed off-limits by Mohamed Hadid. He certainly has a stake in the outcome. Can someone please find out? My guess is he backs Hadid because his silence on the matter is deafening. But if I'm wrong, he could be a game-changer for the countless supporters of the effort to Save Franklin Canyon.
E.M. Fredric
1:39 pm on Thursday, March 31, 2011
"One man sighed and said, "If this was Runyon Canyon, we'd have thousands of hikers show up!""
... tis true... sad but true...
Bill (DOC) Bennett, PhD
3:17 am on Friday, April 1, 2011
Although I now live almost 900 miles due north, when I lived in the area I experienced the beauty of the canyons. I also one a building products company so I understand the canibalistic attitude of developers, but here they can be no happy medium. Is the necessity of all the people in Los Angeles to build on every inch of ground and leave nothing to humanity or the animals. There are other places to build, where your shoddy construction development will not have homes sliding on top of hikers. Just for the hell of it, why not leave something the way GOD MEANT IT TO BE?
E.M. Fredric
1:23 pm on Friday, April 1, 2011
Thanks, Bill! A fundraiser will be coming on April 9th to hire an attorney who helped Benedict Canyon from large development ruining their canyon. Look for 'Conan Stooges' sign and know, that this group of dedicated nature lovers and hikers, isn't going away. Franklin Canyon has been a secret garden for many for too long. www.savefranklincanyon.com will be posting soon.
Rich Duran
12:39 am on Sunday, April 3, 2011
I recently hiked in the canyon with a close friend and was informed about the development. Upon closer scrutiny of this particular developer I went to his other job site located on N. Crescent, directly across the street from the the Beverly Hills Hotel located at 9641 Sunset Blvd, Beverly Hills. I watched the crew on this construction site and noticed that all of the laborers were just that, laborers and not Craftsmen. My oldest son lost his job as a Superintendent for a construction company when the companies hired unskilled illegals to do the labor. I am a retired Union HVAC 608 Certified Technician. Skilled Craftsmen are trained for years on the job and in the classroom. This is still America. I did not see one American Craftsman on that job! My guess is that 80 percent of those workers were undocumented. Just thought I'd add my $0.02 onto this developer's bottom line.
E.M. Fredric
10:38 am on Sunday, April 3, 2011
Thank you for a compelling comment on the workers at N. Crescent in Beverly Hills, maybe someone will take a look into it and see if jobs are being taken away.
Holly
2:25 pm on Sunday, May 29, 2011
Ooooooh, this kind of thing gets me so upset. How sad that these developers have no care for anything but money. How sad that the Conservance didn't stay on top of this, when they should have protected this land. How sad that the people who sold these lots, didn't have a care about the natural environment either. Open space in Los Angeles is rapidly disappearing, one development at a time. Beautiful little spaces are determined to be "under-utilized" lots, which is definitely a subjective assumption.
I'm glad to see that some people are standing up for Franklin Canyon, and hope more will join!