MY MUSE BOX - Cheeseburger, Cheeseburger, Cheeseburger

The Nancy Burger Pt. 2 - Short Order - Nancy Silverton's Burger Joint


My name is Ilona and I’m a burgerholic. 

If this were a perfect world, I’d eat one every day. My perfect job would be to review cheeseburgers around the world… but the world (and life) is not perfect.  I’d be elephantine. Don’t get me wrong, I love elephants – I just don’t want to ape them in weight.

But, I do get to review cheeseburgers for my Patch blog, and I found a new favorite right in my own back yard (well, really “over the hill” )…

Sometime ago I blogged here about the burgers that Nancy Silverton, one of America’s premiere chefs, makes at home. I called them "Nancy Burgers" and told y’all about her perfect ground beef blend, where to buy it and how she recommends cooking them.

Well Nancy, in celebration of her love for burgers, along with her partner, restaurateur Bill Chait, recently opened up her first burger joint, Short Order, located in the famed Los Angeles Farmer’s Market. And though the restaurant is named “Short Order” – it’s anything but fast food. These are real burgers from delicious ground beef cooked to perfection.

For my first visit, I took my friend Cindra, a fellow cheeseburgerholic. We take each other out for lunch for our birthdays, and her choice this year was a Short Order birthday.

The restaurant has a patio with sort of communal sitting downstairs, and a covered deck with separate tables and enclosed room with tables and a bar upstairs.  We wanted to chat and catch up so we took a deuce on the upstairs deck.

Did I mention that Short Order has a full bar – not just wine and beer? It does. So as is our birthday lunch custom, we ordered Bloody Marys. Oops! No Bloody Marys. They don’t make them. They don’t have tomato juice or Bloody Mary mix. Duh – what?! OK, a big negative, and we were disappointed, but we were game, so Cindra decided to try one of Short Order’s “fancy” cocktails – Morning Glory Fizz, a drink consisting of scotch, lemon, sugar, egg white and absinthe. It tasted pretty good – but really was just a variation of the scotch sour. I opted for a vodka martini with olives. Oops! No olives.  They don’t have them  Duh – what?!  But, I could have my martini with a lemon peel.  OK, another negative, but we were there for the burgers.

We both decided on “Ida’s Old School Burger” (named after a 17 year old family friend).  Grass-fed beef, cheddar, pickles, tomato, griddled onion, iceberg lettuce and a secret sauce, all on a homemade bun… it was a “Dagwood” of cheeseburgers.  Burgers are cooked to a perfect medium rare, unless you specify otherwise. Cindra wanted hers more medium-well and I had it the way Nancy wanted me to have it… both of our burgers were just the way we liked them. We ate. We ooh-ed. We ah-ed. We loved every bite.

For our “side,” we went with the old school fries – shoestring style – crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. Yum.

Our waitress, knowing we were disappointedly-deprived of our Bloody Mary’s, brought out a bottle of white wine the restaurant just ordered for its “wine cellar” and gave us a glass on the house.  The wine was good, but the service she gave us and the acknowledgement of our disappointment was even better.

And, since this was a birthday lunch – dessert was in order and Cindra ordered “Nancy’s Favorite Chocolate Chip Cookie” with TCHO chocolate.  It was delicious and big enough I could have put a candle in it. I sang one bar of “Happy Birthday,” anyway. And, it was a happy and satisfying birthday lunch.

Then it was my turn, birthday-wise.  Every year my friend Michael takes me to a fun diner or dive or food truck to indulge my “gourmet” comfort food cravings. He’s also my cheeseburger enabler. A fan of Nancy’s, my husband joined us.  Again, I found myself on the upstairs deck, sipping water that’s served in Mason jars and perusing the menu.

I decided to have another martini (no I’m not trying to revive the martini lunch) with a lemon peel since they still had no tomato juice or olives.

The day was a perfect medium-warm and I decided that, this time, I would try Nancy’s Backyard Burger, made with her blend of dry-aged beef and topped with North Country Smokehouse applewood bacon, comte (cheese), avocado, heirloom tomatoes, onion, iceberg lettuce and spicy mayo. I love all those things, but knew that this was going to be an even bigger “Dagwood” burger, so I asked for everything (but the cheese) on the side… besides I really wanted to taste this incredible grilled beef and cheese with no frills. 

My husband ordered the same burger, but with everything piled on top the way Nancy intended.

Michael opted for Ida’s burger – the one I had on my first visit.

Biting into my Nancy burger, with the beef juicy-ily medium-rare and the cheese melted to perfection, I soared into burger heaven.

This time we ordered the Short Order Spuds which are small potatoes, cooked, crushed, then deep-fried so they’re soft and crunch all in the same bite. Loved them! Michael ordered a vanilla malt which was too thick, it was like eating Hagen Daas vanilla ice cream and not drinking a malt.

Other choices on the menu are delicious-sounding pork, lamb, turkey, and tuna burgers, along with a double-double vegetarian chick pea patty burger, with yogurt sauce, harissa, cucumbers and iceberg lettuce for non-meat eating crowd.

Or you can get a grilled cheese, patty melt, tuna melt, corn pups (miniature corn dogs) or a mac ‘n’ cheese raft to name just a few selections.  And, yes, even a salad or two.

What can I say – other than the full bar doesn’t serve a full menu of cocktails – and the overly sweet, way too thick malt needs a rethinking…

Short Order is long on great burgers.




6333 W. 3rd Street

Los Angeles, CA 90036



No reservations.  First come, first serve

This post is contributed by a community member. The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Patch Media Corporation. Everyone is welcome to submit a post to Patch. If you'd like to post a blog, go here to get started.

Irene DeBlasio March 01, 2012 at 03:08 PM
Ilona, Thank you! I was beginning to think you can't get a medium rare burger anywhere except my house. While you were luxuriating with Nancy Silverton's fine products, I was getting sick at Five Guys on Miracle Mile. Don't even ask...
Ilona Saari March 01, 2012 at 03:32 PM
Oh, I hope you're feeling better, Irene. When you are and want a medium rare burger - but don't want to "go over the hill" - check out the Counter and Umami - both have really delicious burgers. <g>


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something